Menu Icon

The Human Element of Good Copywriting

The Human Element of Good Copywriting
Ask a writer what they think of AI and you'll get a spectrum of responses.
4 min. READ
The Human Element of Good Copywriting
Ask a writer what they think of AI and you'll get a spectrum of responses.

Ask a writer what they think of AI and you'll get a spectrum of responses. Some are ten-toes-down against it. Some are fully ready to outsource their creativity to the robots. Most fall somewhere between.

AI has a great capacity for simplifying and streamlining the way we work, but it can easily become something we over rely on, especially in the creative process. Spend enough time reading AI-generated copy, and you’ll notice some familiar patterns. Swap out the brand name, change the subject and you’re reading the same paragraph from a dozen different companies.

That sameness is becoming harder to ignore. When everyone has access to tools that can generate content in seconds, the internet fills up with more of the same. Familiar phrases, predictable headlines and ideas that are painfully overused and lacking depth. There’s nothing new under the sun.

There's, of course, a place for efficiency, but what happens when we start valuing the speed of producing content more than the thought behind it? Good copywriting requires curiosity, perspective and a willingness to look at something from a dozen different angles until you finally see the shape under the marble slab. It takes digging, chiseling, refining and an embarrassingly large number of discarded headlines. This nitty gritty work is what takes an ordinary message and turns into something worth reading.

Data Can Inform Ideas. It Can't Replace Them.

This is where I think AI has some of its greatest potential in marketing. It can help us make sense of enormous amounts of information, identify patterns, synthesize research and surface insights that might otherwise take hours to uncover.

But data and insights are ingredients, not the finished product. Someone still has to look at the information, ask the right questions and recognize the opportunity hiding in the details. A human brain needs to connect the dots and decide what to do with what they've learned.

The best creative ideas come from curiosity, experience, cultural awareness and letting your mind stew and turn things over long enough to stumble onto something interesting. AI can help inform that process, but the creative direction should remain human-led.

Creativity Is a Muscle. Use It or Lose It.

I think we sometimes underestimate how much practice goes into being creative. We tend to talk about creativity as though it's an innate quality: You either have it or you don't. In reality, creative thinking is a skill we develop through repetition, experimentation and a healthy willingness to get things wrong.

Every brainstorming session, difficult assignment and painfully slow first draft gives us an opportunity to work out the muscle. Not every idea will be a winner. Most won't. But working through the bad ones is often how we find something good.

AI can make it tempting to skip that uncomfortable part. When the blinking cursor and blank page feels intimidating, generating 10 headline options takes almost no effort. When an idea needs work, a quick prompt can produce another round of suggestions. But the more we rely on AI to generate our ideas, make our connections and solve every creative problem, the fewer opportunities we give ourselves to practice those skills.

Over time, that dependence could come at a cost. Creative instincts need exercise. So does the ability to recognize an interesting idea, spot a weak argument or find just the right words to make a message resonate.

Let AI Be a Tool, Not the Creative Director.

The important part is knowing what to hand over and what to keep. A tool can help us work through information, but someone still needs to decide which insights matter. It can generate a dozen campaign concepts, but someone has to bring the experience, perspective and strategic thinking to determine which one is worth pursuing.

That responsibility belongs to the people doing the work. We know the nuances of the brands we represent, the audiences we're trying to reach and the goals we're working toward. We bring years of experience, cultural context and personal perspective to the table. Those things shape the questions we ask and the decisions we make throughout the creative process.

Used well, AI can give us more room to do that work. It can take some of the tedious tasks off our plates and help us get to the interesting questions faster.

The Human Element Makes the Difference.

AI will keep changing the way we work. The tools will get better, the capabilities will expand and we'll find new ways to put them to use.

Some of these capabilities are exciting, but I also hope we keep challenging ourselves to think independently, take creative risks and push past the first idea that’s “good enough” and push for the great one.

The brands and creatives that earn people's attention will need more than a steady stream of good enough content. They'll need fresh perspectives, compelling stories and ideas that reflect a genuine understanding of the people they're trying to reach. Human-to-human connection lands best when it’s driven by — you guessed it — humans.

next article

Connect

with us.

Connect

with us.

Back to the top
SHOW FOOTER
VI Logo Black
close
Close Icon
Google Partner